Clay Studio Series – YouTube Video Review: What type of clay should I use?

What Type of Clay Should I Use? Comparing Three Stoneware Bodies

If there’s one question that potters—especially beginners—ask over and over again, it’s this: “What type of clay should I use?” With so many options available, from smooth white bodies to gritty, speckled stonewares, the choice can feel overwhelming. In this Clay Studio Series feature, we’re reviewing a video that takes the guesswork out by throwing, trimming, and comparing three distinct stoneware clays side by side.

Why This Video Stands Out

Instead of just talking about clay in theory, the potter works directly with three clay bodies and shows the differences in real time. You can see how each clay reacts on the wheel, how it trims when leather-hard, and what kinds of issues may arise depending on the body you choose. This hands-on comparison makes it far easier to understand than simply reading product labels.

The video also tackles a common curiosity: the pink-toned ES80 stoneware, often admired for its warm coloring. The creator points out that this clay is manufactured for reduction firing and won’t give the same results in oxidation, a detail that often gets overlooked by beginners.

Key Lessons for Beginners

Not All Clay is Equal: Some clay bodies are far more forgiving for new potters, while others require more experience to manage.
Know Your Firing Method: Certain clays, like ES80, are formulated specifically for reduction kilns. Using them in an electric oxidation kiln may leave you disappointed.
Texture & Plasticity Matter: Smooth clays can be easier to throw but may slump when trimming. Grittier bodies hold structure but can be harder on your hands.
There’s No Single “Best” Clay: Each clay has its pros and cons — the trick is matching your choice to your skill level and the project you have in mind.

Why We Recommend Watching

For beginners, choosing the right clay can mean the difference between frustration and success. This video demystifies the process by giving a clear visual comparison of three popular stoneware options. By the end, you’ll have a better idea of what qualities to look for in a clay body and which ones might fit your needs best.

For intermediate and advanced potters, the insights are still valuable. Even if you’ve been working with one clay for years, seeing how others handle could inspire you to experiment with something new.

This review proves that clay choice is less about finding a universal “best” and more about learning what works for you. Whether you want smooth, easy-to-handle clay for your first mugs or a robust, grogged body for sculptural pieces, this video is a fantastic guide to help you make a confident decision.

Watch the full video here: What Type of Clay Should I Use?

If you’ve ever fallen down a late-night Pinterest rabbit hole, you’ve probably seen someone suggest boiling polymer clay instead of baking it. At first glance, it sounds clever—no oven needed, just a pot of water and a stove. But does it really work? And more importantly, is it safe?

As someone who’s been working with clay for years (and ruined a few projects along the way), I can tell you that boiling polymer clay is one of those persistent myths that refuses to die. Let’s break it down, look at what really happens when you boil polymer clay, and explore the right ways to cure your clay projects.

Why Polymer Clay Needs Baking, Not Boiling

Polymer clay isn’t like traditional pottery clay that hardens in a kiln, nor is it like homemade playdough that dries out with air. It’s made of PVC particles and plasticizers—and those ingredients need consistent, controlled heat to fuse together.

The magic temperature: Most brands like Sculpey, Fimo, and Premo recommend curing at 265°F–275°F (129°C–135°C).
The timing: Bake for 15–30 minutes per ¼ inch of thickness.
The result: When properly baked, the clay becomes strong, flexible, and durable enough to last decades.

Boiling water only reaches 212°F (100°C)—far below what polymer clay requires. That’s the first red flag.

What Really Happens When You Boil Polymer Clay

So let’s say you drop that cute little charm into boiling water. Here’s what you can expect:

Partial curing only – The outside might harden a little, but the inside stays undercooked. This makes your clay brittle and prone to snapping.
Surface damage – Water moves, bubbles, and churns. That constant agitation can warp details like fine textures, stamps, or sculpted lines.
Chemical leaching – Because polymer clay contains plasticizers, immersing raw clay in water can cause it to sweat sticky residue. Not only does it weaken your clay, but it also ruins the finish.
False confidence – A boiled piece looks firm at first, but give it a few days or weeks and you’ll see cracks, crumbles, and peeling.

Bottom line? Boiling leaves you with fragile, disappointing results.

Boiling vs Baking vs Air Dry Clay: A Quick Comparison

Here’s a handy chart you can pin or save:

Method	Temperature	Strength & Durability	Risks	Best For
Boiling Polymer Clay	212°F (100°C)	Weak, brittle, cracks easily	Warping, sticky residue, not fully cured	Not recommended
Baking Polymer Clay	265–275°F (129–135°C)	Strong, flexible, long-lasting	Can scorch if overheated	Jewelry, ornaments, figurines
Air Dry Clay	Room temp	Light but fragile; not waterproof	Cracking if dried too fast	Kids’ crafts, décor, lightweight projects

Where the Boiling Myth Comes From

It’s easy to see where the confusion starts:

Cold porcelain clay (a DIY clay made from cornstarch and glue) is sometimes cooked or simmered on the stovetop.
Air dry clays harden naturally without any heat at all.
Pottery clay is hardened in kilns but sometimes pre-soaked or pre-conditioned in water.

Polymer clay often gets lumped in with these clays, but it plays by a completely different rulebook.

Alternatives If You Don’t Want to Use the Kitchen Oven

Some crafters hesitate to bake clay in the same oven they cook dinner in. Totally understandable! Luckily, there are safe alternatives:

1. A Dedicated Toaster Oven

A tabletop toaster oven is a crafter’s best friend. Small, cheap, and just the right size for jewelry, beads, and figurines. Just pop an oven thermometer inside to keep things accurate.

2. A Clay-Specific Oven

Some craft brands sell little ovens designed just for polymer clay. They’re not essential, but they give peace of mind if you worry about fumes in your main oven.

3. Heat Gun or Embossing Tool

These work for small flat pieces (like earrings) but require a careful hand—hold it too long and you’ll scorch the clay.

4. Skip Polymer, Choose Air Dry Clay

If you really don’t want to bake at all, switch to air dry clay. It hardens on its own (no oven required), though it won’t be as durable or waterproof as polymer clay.

Safety Tips for Baking Polymer Clay

If the oven still makes you nervous, here’s how to bake with confidence:

Always use an oven thermometer. Most ovens run hotter or cooler than the dial suggests.
Tent your clay. Lay a piece of foil loosely over your project to protect from scorching.
Keep clay tools separate. Dedicate a baking tray, foil, and even a cookie sheet just for clay use.
Don’t overbake. Follow the instructions on the package—overheating clay can darken it and release an unpleasant smell.

Done right, polymer clay is perfectly safe to cure in a home oven.

FAQs About Boiling & Baking Polymer Clay

Q: Can I boil clay jewelry like beads or pendants?
Nope! They’ll be weak, crumbly, and won’t last. Stick with baking.

Q: Is it dangerous to boil polymer clay?
It won’t explode, but it can release residue and ruin your pot. Save your cookware for cooking, not crafts.

Q: Can I microwave polymer clay?
No. Microwaving polymer clay doesn’t cure it—it just overheats it unevenly, often burning the surface while leaving the inside raw.

Q: What if I only have air dry clay?
That’s fine! Just remember it’s not the same as polymer clay. It won’t be waterproof or as strong but works beautifully for lightweight crafts.

The Verdict: Don’t Boil, Just Bake

So, can you boil polymer clay? Technically, yes—you can dunk it in a pot of water. But should you? Absolutely not. Boiling doesn’t cure it properly, leaves your creations fragile, and can ruin all the hard work you put into shaping, texturing, and designing.

If you want long-lasting jewelry, ornaments, and keepsakes, baking is the way to go. And if you’d rather avoid baking altogether, explore air dry clays or cold porcelain—clays designed for that style of crafting.

Give your clay creations the proper heat treatment they deserve, and they’ll reward you with years of beauty and strength.